“The national government will maintain and defend the foundations on which the power of our nation rests. It will offer strong protection to Christianity as the very basis of our collective morality. Today Christians stand at the head of our country. We want to fill our culture again with the Christian spirit. We want to burn out all the recent immoral developments in literature, in the theatre, and in the press … in short, we want to burn out the poison of immorality which has entered into our whole life and culture as a result of liberal excess during the past few years.”
From The Speeches of Adolph Hitler, 1922-1939, Vol. 1, pg. 871-872 (London, Oxford University Press, 1942.)
JUNE, 2004 THROUGH THE PRESENT
|
|
|
click here for columns from January 2000 through May 2004
click
here for columns from April, 1996 to December, 1999
|
|
|
![]() |
|
| Article
about Lee Thorn's Jhai Foundation Article on cluster bombs in Laos Click here to order one of the finest coffees in the world To learn more about the Jhai Foundation |
![]() |
December 1, 2007 (from
their December 1, 2003 column) In Which Sam
& Abby Discuss New Research On The Immediate Treatment For
Psychological Trauma, And The Remarkably Effective Non-Drug Treatment
For Depression
Sam The Cockapoo: Abby, I've been reading
some interesting articles in the Harvard
Mental Health Letter (November
2003) that I found on the desk here in the office.
Abby The Labrador: What did you read there,
Sam?
Sam: The first one is about the immediate treatments for
traumatic psychological stress. For many years, the
accepted way of helping has been "critical incident stress debriefing,"
in which the person is encouraged to talk about the details of what
happened to them--e.g., if they were involved in a terrible automobile
accident, or a wildfire that destroyed all of the homes in their
neighborhood--and to express some of their feelings about it while
being told that the feelings are normal.
Abby: That makes sense. People don't want to just hold it all
in and get stuck with all of that trauma, do they?
Sam: You'd think not, Abby. But in reality, what these
researchers found when they looked at several studies was that this
debriefing was more effective than other treatments in 3 studies, in 6
studies it made no difference, and in 2 studies it was actually worse.
Abby: Hmmmm. That's pretty thought-provoking, Sam.
Sam: Yes. In this
type of treatment, the procedure is only done once. They suggested that
it wasn't enough time for victims of trauma to really process the event
sufficiently; and also, that our brains may do better by pushing the
experience away for awhile in order to give us time to let it sink in
more slowly. That's one of the important, positive functions of denial.
It keeps our circuits from overloading.
Abby: So it would appear that more traditional, ongoing
psychotherapy might be better in the long run?
Sam: Yes, it would appear so.
Abby: That makes even more sense to me, Sam. If you watch
humans over the years, you'll notice that the healthier ones take time
to talk with their companions about things like this in smaller doses,
and certainly more often than once, over a longer period of time.
Sam: And the less healthy ones don't talk about it much at
all, either because they don't have any companions with whom to share,
or because they believe that it is a sign of strength not to share
painful experiences and feelings.
Abby: What else does the article say?
Sam: It says that Inderal (propranolol), a beta-blocker that
is used for high blood pressure and stage fright, can actually "slow
the formation of emotionally disturbing memories. In two preliminary,
controlled studies published this year, immediate treatment with
propranolol (within hours or days after the trauma) reduced
post-traumatic symptoms and lowered the risk of PTSD.
Abby: PTSD?
Sam: Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder. It's the longterm
disorder that can result from a traumatic event. Months or years later,
people can have nightmares, flashbacks, emotional numbing, depression,
and related symptoms.
Abby: This is fascinating, Sam. What else have you been
reading?
Sam: Last year I overheard Dad and Mom discussing the results
of research at Duke University on the treatment of depression without
medication. I just looked it up using a "Google Search," and I found
this press release from September, 2000. It is astounding, if you ask
me...
DURHAM, N.C. - After demonstrating
that 30 minutes of brisk exercise three times a week is just as
effective as drug therapy in relieving the symptoms of major depression
in the short term, Duke University Medical Center researchers have now
shown that continued exercise greatly reduces the chances of the
depression returning.
Last year, the Duke researchers reported on their study of 156
older patients diagnosed with major depression which, to their
surprise, found that after 16 weeks, patients who exercised showed
statistically significant and comparable improvement relative to those
who took anti-depression medication, or those who
took the medication and exercised. (Italics and underlining
added by Sam)
The new study, which followed the same participants for an additional six months, found that patients who continued to exercise after completing the initial trial were much less likely to see their depression return than the other patients. Only 8 percent of patients in the exercise group had their depression return, while 38 percent of the drug-only group and 31 percent of the exercise-plus-drug group relapsed.
"The important conclusion is that the effectiveness of exercise seems to persist over time, and that patients who respond well to exercise and maintain their exercise have a much smaller risk of relapsing," said lead researcher, Duke psychologist James Blumenthal, who published the results of his team's study in the October issue of the journal Psychosomatic Medicine.
The research was supported by grants from the National Institutes of Health (NIH). The Duke researchers are now using a new $3 million NIH grant to better understand the subtle factors that may explain the positive effects of exercise in a new trial that begins enrolling patients this month.
"We found that there was an inverse relationship between exercise and the risk of relapsing - the more one exercised, the less likely one would see their depressive symptoms return," Blumenthal explained. "For each 50-minute increment of exercise, there was an accompanying 50 percent reduction in relapse risk.
"Findings from these studies indicate that a modest exercise program is an effective and robust treatment for patients with major depression," he continued. "And if these motivated patients continue with their exercise, they have a much better chance of not seeing their depression return."
Researchers were surprised that the group of patients who took the medication and exercised did not respond as well as those who only exercised.
"We had assumed that exercise and medication together would have had an additive effect, but this turned out not to be the case," Blumenthal said. "While we don't know the reasons for this, some of the participants were disappointed when they found out they were randomized to the exercise and medication group. To some extent, this 'anti-medication' sentiment may have played a role by making patients less excited or enthused about their combined exercise and medication program."
He suggested that exercise may be beneficial because patients are actually taking an active role in trying to get better.
"Simply taking a pill is very passive," he said. "Patients who exercised may have felt a greater sense of mastery over their condition and gained a greater sense of accomplishment. They may have felt more self-confident and competent because they were able to do it themselves, and attributed their improvement to their ability to exercise."
Once patients start feeling better, they tend to exercise more, which makes them feel even better, Blumenthal said. The greatest risk for these patients, since they are older, would be to suffer an injury or illness that would interrupt their exercise routine, he added.
While the researchers enrolled middle-aged and elderly people in their study, Blumenthal said it is logical to assume that the results would hold true for the general population, since older people tend to have additional medical problems or infirmities that might make regular exercise more difficult than for younger patients.
Researchers used the anti-depressant sertraline (trade name Zoloft), which is a member of a class of commonly used anti-depressants known as selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors (SSRI).
Blumenthal cautioned that the study did not include patients who were acutely suicidal or had what is termed psychotic depression. Also, since patients were recruited by advertisements, these patients were motivated to get better and interested in exercise.
The research team included, from Duke, Michael Babyak, Steve Herman, Parinda Khatri, Dr. Murali Doraiswamy, Kathleen Moore, Teri Baldewicz and Dr. Ranga Krishnan. Edward Craighead, from the University of Colorado at Boulder also participated.
August 1, 2007 In Which Sam
& Abby Say Goodbye To Two Of Mom And Dad's Dear Friends
IN
Memoriam: Anne Subby of Minneapolis, Minnesota and Lynda Winter,
of Dayton, Ohio, both passed away in early August after valiant and
courageous struggles with cancer over the past several years. Both
women were psychotherapists, mothers, and grandmothers, and worked
countless miracles in this world while they were here. They will be
sorely missed, and we extend our prayers, our heartfelt gratitude, and
our good wishes of peace and serenity to their loved ones over the
coming months.
John & Linda Friel, August 11, 2007
May 1, 2007 In Which Sam & Abby Describe One Man's Reconciliation With His Pain, And How We Can Give Meaning To Our Lives In An Increasingly Confusing World [from their January 1, 2004 column]
Article
about Lee Thorn's Jhai Foundation
Article
on cluster bombs in Laos
Click
here to order one of the finest coffees in the world
To learn more about
the Jhai Foundation, Click here
Abby The Labrador: Happy New Year, Sam.
Sam The Cockapoo: Likewise, Abby.
Abby: I have been organizing my observations about human
beings over the past year, and pondering the state of the world on this first day of 2004.
Humans are becoming increasingly troubled, I think. And increasingly
polarized.
Sam: Dad and Mom say it happens because of anxiety. The more
frightened people become, the more they seek simplistic,
black-and-white solutions to life's problems.
Abby: Yes. And, it is a confusing world. But what I also
realized is that there are millions of humans who are not falling prey to that kind of
thinking. They have found a way to care about the world, and each
other, despite all the polarization. But we hardly hear anything about them.
Sam: I know, Ab. That's the sad part. Here in America, if it
isn't violent or dramatic or scary, it isn't likely to make the evening
news, and if it doesn't make the evening news, most Americans aren't
likely to hear about it.
Abby: That's why I found it so heart warming to read about
Vietnam veteran Lee Thorn and his reconciliation work in Laos, as well
as the work of the Mennonite Central Committee (MCC) and the Mines
Advisory Group (MAG) in that same country. Together, they are helping
to slowly--and I mean slowly--reverse the horrible damage that was done
to this rural country. Between 1964 and 1973, America conducted a
secret air war in which over 2 million tons of bombs were dropped on
Laos, making it the most heavily bombed country in history.
This secret war, which was in clear violation of international law, eventually came to light during Senate investigations, but the aftermath goes on, today.
The country is now littered with millions of unexploded
tennis ball-sized cluster bombs, called "bombies," that look like toys,
making them especially dangerous for the children of Laos. Tens of
thousands of Laotians continue to be killed or maimed by these cluster
bombs. The MCC and MAG have instituted a comprehensive program to
explode and remove the cluster bombs, and so far have removed hundreds
of thousands of them.
Sam: That is incredible, Abby. It is unbelievable, too. How
could the United States military conduct such a massive air campaign in
secret?
Abby: Sadly, these things happen all the time. Read your
history books. You'll see.
Sam: Where does Lee Thorn enter into the picture?
Abby: Lee Thorn loaded bombs on U.S. planes on the U.S.S.
Ranger in the Gulf of Tonkin during this secret war, and then he had to
screen film footage of the destruction caused by those bombs. He had
nightmares. In 1998, he and a friend brought 200 pounds of medical
supplies to Laos in response to a plea for help. As a result of that
initial effort to help, he has not only healed much of the
post-traumatic stress with which he has struggled, but he has also set
up, along with Bounthanh Phommasathit, a foundation to help with
medical and educational services in Laos. "Jhai" means "hearts and minds working together."
Sam: What a wonderful word for this confusing 21st century.
Abby: Yes, isn't it, though?
Now, they are in the process of developing pedal-powered
wireless computers so that villagers in Laos can be connected to the
outside world. This particular project has gained prominence on an
international scale.
Sam: Where does the coffee come in?
Abby: Laotian Arabica Typica beans, brought to Laos by the
French in the 1930's, are considered to be among the best in the entire
world, due to the perfect growing conditions there. Much of the funding
for the Jhai Foundation has come through selling this coffee. And in
addition, the Laotian farmers get paid above the global Fair Trade
value for it.
Sam: It sounds like an amazing journey for so many people,
Abby. Hurt, healing, hope, reconciliation.
Abby: Yes, Sam, it is. I just thought it would be nice to
start out 2004 with a story that could well have remained a disaster
indefinitely, but that through the efforts of some caring, dedicated
people, will end up on a much better note.
Sam: And who knows? Maybe someone will read our column and
buy some of that Jhai coffee!
Abby: They'd win all the way around--the best coffee in the
world, and a chance to clean up some terrible stains from our recent
past. When we bring our better part forward, who knows what great
things can happen!
Sam & Abby: We end our January column, below, with a
Happy New Year greeting from Lee Thorn. We wish you all the best in
2004.
Happy New Year
From Jhai Foundation
April 1, 2007 In Which Sam And Abby Discuss The Weather In Minnesota, And How To Talk To Kids About Difficult Things [from the dynamic duo's column from April, 2000]
Sam The Cockapoo: What a weird month March was! A few weeks ago we had several days in a row when all the high temperature records were broken--it was GREAT--and then it snowed! The poor geese and ducks had begun returning in droves--er, flocks--and the ice had all melted off of the ponds and lakes, and then one day the geese were walking around on the ice again, floating in the water as ice formed around them, and trying to stay warm.
Abby The Labrador: It was bizarre, Sam. Now the geese are all paired up and are doing their mating dances, which is really noisy. They're chasing each other around, twirling their necks, poking at each other, honking and cackling and gurgling--it's quite a display of instinctual behavior.
Sam: Yes. And it's finally beginning to warm up in the usual way it does at about this time. It's supposed to be a high of 55 degrees, not the 78 degrees it was several weeks ago. I loved it when it was so warm, but I don't mind it once it gets above 50 degrees, especially if it's sunny and not too windy. It's perfect weather to go for a long run and then snooze in the sun on our beds that are right in front of the sliding glass doors leading out onto the deck. Southern exposure. We get that "snoozing sun" all afternoon.
Abby: You're quite the connoisseur of weather and sun these days, Sam.
Sam: Oh, yes, Abby. I am.
Abby: Sam, I saw this on Dad's desk the other day.
Sam: What is it?
Abby: It looks like the script he and Mom were working on with Rebecca when she came up for Dad's birthday a few weeks ago. It's for that parenting videotape he made down in Chicago, for Allyn & Bacon Publishers. It's part of a series called Parenting With The Experts, in which each tape is made by a different expert in the field, and they do four teaching exercises per tape. John Gray, who wrote Men Are From Mars, Women Are From Venus did the first tape. Dad did the second. And they have people like Harville Hendrix, Harriet Lerner, Bill Pollack, Sylvia Rimm, John Covey, and Bill Doherty signed up to do the others.
Sam: Wow! What a group! So, what did Dad do on his tape?
Abby: He did exercises on how to talk to children about difficult things.
Sam: That's pretty timely, given all the things that have been going on in families lately.
Abby: Yes. It starts out with an exercise for parents on how to identify and label their own feelings. The idea behind it is that if parents aren't aware of what they're feeling, they can get "hijacked" by them, as Daniel Goleman called it in Emotional Intelligence. And when our unconscious feelings hijack us, we do or say things that we later regret.
Sam: That sounds like a good way to start. It looks like in the second half of that exercise, he had them focus on fear, shame , guilt, loneliness, and sadness, because these are the more vulnerable feelings that can lead to things like rage. Good idea.
Abby: And the next exercise is about how parents can manage their own anxiety and guilt so that these feelings don't cause them to react to their kids in really immature ways. For example, if you tell your child she has to go to her room for ten minutes because she hit her brother, she might turn around and yell, "I hate you, Mommy!" If Mommy were to say, "Oooh, that hurts Mommy's feelings when you say that," Mommy is manipulating her daughter, and teaching her daughter to be manipulative in return. But if Mommy were to say, "Yes, you're angry. I understand. And you have to go to your room for ten minutes," then Mommy is acting like an adult, and daughter will learn how to manage her feelings and reactions appropriately.
Sam: That's good stuff. Let's see. The next one is how to teach without lecturing, because lecturing is the WORST way to teach things or correct behavior. No one can keep from zoning out when they're getting a lecture in a one-on-one situation. It's natural for your eyes to glaze over and for you to dissociate when someone is droning on and on with a lecture. But there is a very good way to teach without lecturing--by demonstrating your own thought process when you're faced with a similar problem. Dad and Mom discuss this in their parenting book, in the chapter on impulse control.
Abby: And then the last exercise is how to respond to your child when he or she shares some really painful experience, or is confused about something. That's the one that Rebecca and Mom helped the most with.
Sam: Yes. I remember them talking about it.
Abby: Yes. If your child comes to you with a problem, like a friend no longer likes them, or even more difficult, that they think they may be depressed or in some kind of trouble, it is very important for parents to LISTEN, NOT GIVE ADVICE. And to KEEP THE CONVERSATION FLOWING BY ASKING SPECIFIC QUESTIONS, like "Where were you when your friend said that she didn't want to be friends anymore?" and "Were there other kids around?" And to SET ASIDE YOUR OWN BELIEFS AND AND ANXIETY FOR THE TIME BEING, so that your child feels heard. There is time later to give advice if in fact it is really needed, but in most cases, if an adult or child has someone to listen, he or she can usually figure out how to solve the problem on their own.
Sam: You know, The U.S. Secret Service just released a report on kids and teenagers who get guns and shoot others, and one of the facts they discovered is that the kids didn't have any adults that they felt they could talk to. It seems like this is pretty important stuff for parents to work on.
Abby: Yes. Keeping the lines of communication open, and MAKING ENOUGH TIME in your lives so that kids feel they can approach you with their problems, and then not imposing your own advice and anxiety on them, are crucial to having healthy kids.
Sam: It sounds good to me, Abby. I hope parents can do more of that with their children instead of lecturing or trying to "fix" things for their kids. Parents need to encourage their kids to work their feelings through.
Abby: It will make for much healthier families.
Sam: Well, Abby, speaking of health. It's time for our run. It looks like Dad is putting on his running shoes!
Abby: This is going to be a great month, Sam! I can feel it in my bones!!![]() |
|||
![]() |
--- 98 Days, 13 Hours, 14 Minutes, 47 Seconds until the 2007 Dipsea Race --- Latest News: |
||
Abby The Labrador: This is fascinating, Sam. And very sensible.
Sam The Cockapoo: You're doing it again, Ab.
Abby: What, Sam?
Sam: Beginning your sentence in the middle of your thoughts, as if I've been privy to your private thoughts all along. What are you referring to?
Abby: Oh, sorry, Sam. I'm looking at some notes on the desk here...about the relationship between power, perpetration, humility, graciousness, and dependency.
Sam: And?
Abby: Well, think about it. Think about a bully...someone who has power but uses it in a mean or disrespectful way. He hurts people's feelings, steps on people's toes, insults people, says cruel things, and then when someone points out how he's hurt you, he turns it around and makes it about the person he's insulted, as in, "Oh, you're too sensitive," or "What's the matter, can't you take a joke," or "You're all just out to get me."
Sam: Wow! That IS remarkable! Remember that big bully dog down by the lake? HE was like that. He was this big, tough, muscular bulldog and he'd scare other dogs, insult them, make fun of their normal canine limitations--after all, we ALL have normal canine limitations--and the thing that's REALLY fascinating is that you and I caught ourselves both admiring his candor and sort of feeling protective of him at first. He seemed so "honest" and "right out there."
Abby: Yes. That's what's so interesting about this. When someone is a perpetrator, that's what happens. He can't allow himself to acknowledge his shame, and when you can't acknowledge your shame, you're automatically a perpetrator. So he's broken. And caring canines can sense that broken-ness, and at first we feel protective.
Sam: Wow!
Abby: You can say that again. Shame is the feeling that asks us to be accountable for our actions, and it lets us have humility. Because every creature is imperfect, there will be times in every creature's existence when he must admit that he is flawed. And when those flaws hurt others, the shame lets him admit that he has hurt others, which helps relationships heal. If he is too weak to admit his flaws, then his relationships with others will always be damaged or damaging.
Sam: So being able to admit that we're defective is a sign of STRENGTH, not weakness.
Abby: Oh, definitely. It's called having ego strength--or the ability to be effective and competent in the world, while also being respectful. People who don't have a lot of inner strength get stuck as either victims or perpetrators. They don't have HEALTHY POWER.
Sam: It would seem that having healthy power would also include the ability to acknowledge that at times we need each other, and that there are those who are more competent or powerful than us, and that at times we need to depend on their strength.
Abby: Of course! How else would we continue to grow and learn and mature? Truly powerful people are able to admit that at times they don't have the answers, and that they need to rely on a higher authority or a creature with more knowledge or wisdom.
Sam: So, it would be like me giving a "helping hand up" to someone younger or less wise than me, but then also being willing to ask for a helping hand up when I need it.
Abby: Exactly. As soon as you believe that you can't learn from anyone else, you've become grandiose, a perpetrator.
Sam: Is this ability to ask for help the same as being hopelessly dependent?
Abby: Not at all. Powerful creatures are self-reliant and competent. They just aren't arrogant. And they know that creatures like dogs, baboons, and humans are social animals, and therefore depend on each other for survival.
Sam: Now let me get this straight. We're talking about someone who says or implies that it's weak to admit one's flaws. And we're talking about someone who looks down on those who know that they don't have all the answers. And we're talking about someone who doesn't admit his shame, and denies that he feels fear. (Fear gives us wisdom, of course). So we're saying that this dog or person is admitting that he is a perpetrator, which is a distorted use of power, and that he is therefore weak. Right?
Abby: Right, Sam. Good. REAL POWER, HEALTHY POWER, is power that is tempered by humility, graciousness, and acknowledgment of one's need to rely on others. Look at Nelson Mandela. Talk about power. He turned around an entire nation that seemed to be hopelessly trapped in the misery of apartheid. And he did it humbly, by spending 27 years or so in prison. They tried to cut deals with him year after year, if only he would give up his goal of creating a fair and equal government in South Africa. But he never gave in.
Sam: It's awe inspiring and humbling just to think of what he did. What amazing power!
Abby: Yes. And that's the point. Compare him to the neighborhood bully who can make people cower in fear. So what if the bully can force creatures to do things? What does that prove? That he's scared, lonely, arrogant, grandiose, and hollow. Abuse of power is weak. It isn't respectful. And in the end, bullies lose everything.
Sam: Boy. This is great. I have a whole month's worth of stuff to ponder now. Just in time for the first snowfall.
Abby: Wha...?
Sam: No, it isn't going to snow just yet, Ab. But it won't be long.
Abby: Good grief, Sam! Dogs get so GOOFY in the snow! I wonder why that is?
Sam: I haven't a clue. Must be in our genes, because all dogs do it.
Abby: What are genes?
Sam: Uh...we're done for this month. Say "Goodnight," Ab.
Abby: "Goodnight, Ab."

October 1, 2006 Sam and Abby Will be
Holding Their Breath Until The Elections Are Over And The Results
Tabulated In Early November. They Are Sore Afraid That Unless Something
Changes, Their Beloved America Will Suffer More Than She Has In Decades
September 1, 2006 In
which Sam and Abby Reproduce A Quote From RFK Regarding Materialism vs.
Meaning And Depth
"Too much and too long, we seem to have
surrendered community excellence and community values in the mere
accumulation of material things. Our gross national product...if we
should judge American by that - counts air pollution and cigarette
advertising, and ambulances to clear our highways of carnage. It counts
special locks for our doors and the jails for those who break them. It
counts the destruction of our redwoods and the loss of our natural
wonder in chaotic sprawl. It counts napalm and the cost of a nuclear
warhead, and armored cars for police who fight riots in our streets. It
counts Whitman's rifle and Speck's knife, and the television programs
which glorify violence in order to sell toys to our children. "Yet the gross national product does not allow for the health of our
children, the quality of their education, or the joy of their play. It
does not include the beauty of our poetry or the strength of our
marriages; the intelligence of our public debate or the integrity of
our public officials. It measures neither our wit nor our courage;
neither our wisdom nor our learning; neither our compassion nor our
devotion to our country; it measures everything, in short, except that
which makes life worthwhile. And it tells us everything about America
except why we are proud that we are Americans." Robert F. Kennedy,
Address, University of
Kansas, Lawrence, Kansas, March 18, 1968.
August 1, 2006 In
which Sam and Abby Wish Dad & Mom "Happy 25th Anniversary!"
July 1, 2006 In
which Sam and Abby Talk
About Robert Kennedy's profoundly compassionate and healing impromptu
speech in Indianapolis upon hearing of Martin Luther King's
assassination--It's what celebrating the birth of America is really
about
Abby The Labrador: What are you reading there, old Sam.
Sam The Cockapoo: It's an excerpt in Time Magazine from Joe
Klein's new book about how political consultatnts have all but
destroyed the political process, or at the very least, political
discourse, in America.
Abby: What's the title of the
book?
Sam: Politics Lost: How American
Democracy Was Trivialized by People Who Think You Are Stupid
Abby: Interesting title, Sam.
Sam: Yes. I
overheard Dad reading this section of the essay to Mom the other day,
and he was almost in tears as he read it. He said that not only was
that moment in history so sad and so touching--the African-Americans in
the crowd were so hurt, so crushed by the news--but he was also so sad
to acknowledge that politicians today are so programmed, so shallow, so
afraid of saying anything
at all that might have any meaning or value, that it overwhelmed him
for a moment. Read what Bobby Kennedy said, off the top of his head, in
what had to be one of the most difficult, anxious moments that any
speaker has ever had to face. Joe Klein wrote...
On the evening of April 4, 1968, about an hour after Martin Luther King Jr. was assassinated, Robert F. Kennedy responded with a powerfully simple speech, which he delivered spontaneously in a black neighborhood of Indianapolis. Nearly 40 years later, Kennedy's words stand as an example of the substance and music of politics in its grandest form and highest purpose—to heal, to educate, to lead. Sadly, his speech also marked the end of an era: the last moments before American public life was overwhelmed by marketing professionals, consultants and pollsters who, with the flaccid acquiescence of the politicians, have robbed public life of much of its romance and vigor.
Kennedy, who was running for the Democratic presidential nomination, had a dangerous job that night. His audience was unaware of King's assassination. He had no police or Secret Service protection. His aides were worried that the crowd would explode as soon as it learned the news; there were already reports of riots in other cities. His speechwriters Adam Walinsky and Frank Mankiewicz had drafted remarks for the occasion, but Kennedy rejected them. He had scribbled a few notes of his own. "Ladies and gentlemen," he began, rather formally, respectfully. "I'm only going to talk to you just for a minute or so this evening because I have some very sad news ..." His voice caught, and he turned it into a slight cough, a throat clearing, "and that is that Martin Luther King was shot and was killed tonight in Memphis, Tennessee."
There were screams, wailing—just the rawest, most visceral sounds of pain that human voices can summon. As the screams died, Kennedy resumed, slowly, pausing frequently, measuring his words: "Martin Luther King ... dedicated his life ... to love ... and to justice between fellow human beings, and he died in the cause of that effort." There was near total silence now. One senses, listening to the tape years later, the audience's trust in the man on the podium, a man who didn't merely feel the crowd's pain but shared it. And Kennedy reciprocated: he laid himself bare for them, speaking of the death of his brother—something he'd never done publicly and rarely privately—and then he said, "My favorite poem, my favorite poet was Aeschylus. He once wrote, 'Even in our sleep, pain which cannot forget falls drop by drop upon the heart,'" he paused, his voice quivering slightly as he caressed every word. The silence had deepened, somehow; the moment was stunning. "'Until ... in our own despair, against our will, comes wisdom through the awful grace of God.'"
Listen to Kennedy's Indianapolis speech and there is a quality of respect for the audience that simply is not present in modern American politics. It isn't merely that he quotes Aeschylus to the destitute and uneducated, although that is remarkable enough. Kennedy's respect for the crowd is not only innate and scrupulous, it is also structural, born of technological innocence: he doesn't know who they are--not scientifically, the way post-modern politicians do. The audience hasn't been sliced and diced by his pollsters, their prejudices and policy priorities cross-tabbed, their favorite words discovered by carefully targeted focus groups. He hasn't been told what not to say to them: Aeschylus would never survive a focus group. Kennedy knows certain things, to be sure: they are poor, they are black, they are aggrieved and quite possibly furious. But he doesn't know too much. He is therefore less constrained than subsequent generations of politicians, freer to share his extravagant humanity with them.
"Television,"
Walinsky said many years after his Kennedy
apprenticeship, "has ruined every single thing it has touched." There
was some puckishness to this—he was talking about professional
basketball, if I remember correctly—but Walinsky is a serious man and
he wasn't really joking. Yes, television has been a wondrous thing.
Vast numbers of people now watch presidential debates, State of the
Union messages, prime-time press conferences, not to mention terrorist
attacks, hurricanes and wars in real time. But television also set off
a chain reaction that transformed the very nature of politics. "This is
the beginning of a whole new concept," said a very young Roger Ailes as
he stage-managed Richard Nixon's 1968 presidential campaign. "This is
the way they'll be elected forevermore. The next guys up will have to
be performers." Television brought other changes as well. Suddenly,
politicians were able to use televised advertising to communicate in a
more powerful and intimate (and negative) way than ever before—and
suddenly politicians had to raise vast sums of money to pay for those
ads. Television demanded transparency, and so the rules of politics had
to change as well: no more selection of presidential candidates in
smoke-filled rooms.
Abby: "Even in our
sleep, pain which cannot forget falls drop by
drop upon the heart, until ... in our own despair, against
our will, comes
wisdom through the awful grace of God."
Sam: You can listen to the
actual speech by clicking on the blue highlighted text above. I did,
and I was in tears.
Abby: Happy Birthday, America. We
hope you continue to fulfill your promise as a beacon of courage,
wisdom, and true moral leadership, rather than wallowing in shallow
displays of hollow sound bites and moral platitudes.
June 1, 2006 In
which Sam and Abby Discuss John F. Kennedy's Speech in Honor of Robert
Frost at Amherst College, Less Than A Month Before His Assassination
Sam The Cockapoo: I've been reading the January/February
issue of The Atlantic Monthly
that Dad and Mom left out on the coffee table. I can see why they were
getting weepy when they read this particular article.
Abby The Labrador: Why, Sam?
Sam: It's a brief speech that President John F. Kennedy gave at Amherst College less than a month before he was assassinated.
Abby: Were they weepy because he was killed?
Sam: The whole world seemed to weep when he was
killed, but after reading this, I think they were weeping for their
grandchildren.
Abby: How so?
Sam: Read this speech. Let his words and their
meanings penetrate into the far reaches of your heart and soul. Can you
imagine ANY politician or potential leader expressing such
gracious, noble, powerful thoughts today? I think they were weepng
because they are so sad at what has happened to the country they love
so much--to Republicans, Democrats, the corporate world, and above all,
the media. I read an article the other day that was noting the
brilliance and foresight of President Dwight D. Eisenhower's admonition
that we be wary of the "military-industrial complex," and then adding
that what Ike could not have forseen is that the other leg of that
dangerous 3-legged beast is the corporately-controlled media. To wit,
there is no real news, no real debate about which candidate is better
than the other. Dad's sister is a mentor teacher and student of
history, and she says that hope springs eternal when it comes to
democracy in America. I pray that she is right.
Abby: I think I'll read JFK's speech now.
nation reveals itself not only by the men it
produces but also by the men it honors, the men it remembers …
The men who create power make an indispensable contribution to the nation's greatness, but the men who question power make a contribution just as indispensable, especially when that questioning is disinterested, for they determine whether we use power or power uses us …
When power leads man toward arrogance, poetry reminds him of his limitations. When power narrows the areas of man's concern, poetry reminds him of the richness and diversity of his existence. When power corrupts, poetry cleanses, for art establishes the basic human truths which must serve as the touchstones of our judgment. The artist, however faithful to his personal vision of reality, becomes the last champion of the individual mind and sensibility against an intrusive society and an officious state. The great artist is thus a solitary figure. He has, as Frost said, "a lover's quarrel with the world." In pursuing his perceptions of reality he must often sail against the currents of his time …
If sometimes our great artists have been the most critical of our society, it is because their sensitivity and their concern for justice, which must motivate any true artist, make them aware that our nation falls short of its highest potential.
I see little of more importance to the future of our country and our civilization than full recognition of the place of the artist. If art is to nourish the roots of our culture, society must set the artist free to follow his vision wherever it takes him …
In free society art is not a weapon, and it does not belong to the sphere of polemics and ideology. Artists are not engineers of the soul. It may be different elsewhere. But in a democratic society the highest duty of the writer, the composer, the artist, is to remain true to himself and to let the chips fall where they may. In serving his vision of the truth, the artist best serves his nation …
I look forward to a great future for America—a future in which our country will match its military strength with our moral strength, its wealth with our wisdom, its power with our purpose.
I look forward to an America which will not be afraid of grace and beauty, which will protect the beauty of our natural environment, which will preserve the great old American houses and squares and parks of our national past, and which will build handsome and balanced cities for our future.
I look forward to an America which will reward achievement in the arts as we reward achievement in business or statecraft.
I look forward to an America which will steadily raise the standards of artistic accomplishment and which will steadily enlarge cultural opportunities for all of our citizens.
And I look forward to an America which commands respect throughout the world, not only for its strength but for its civilization as well.
And I look forward to a world which will be safe, not only for democracy and diversity but also for personal distinction.
May 1, 2006 In which Sam and Abby Repeat
Their April and May Columns From 1999
May 1, 1999 In Which Sam And Abby Discuss The Signs Of Summer's Approach, The Beginnings Of Their Book About Humans, And Other Pithy Topics
Abby The Labrador: Sam!!
Sam The Cockapoo: What!!??
Abby: It's WARM out!
Sam: And the lilacs have leaves on them.
Abby: And the oak trees have buds popping out.
Sam: And the geese are back.
Abby: And Dad's taken us for a run three times this week.
Sam: I am SO happy!
Abby: Me, too, Sammy! It's that time of year again.
Sam: What else is happening this month, oh wise Labrador?
Abby: Well, Dave is graduating from college in two weeks.
Sam: He is? Boy, time sure has been flying by. Why, I remember when he was just a little tike.
Abby: No you don't, Sam. You're only 6 1/2 years old. I'm 9 1/2 years old. When you joined the family, Dave was already full grown, and off puppy chow.
Sam: Humans don't eat puppy chow.
Abby: Well, he was full grown, anyway.
Sam: It's amazing how much happens in just four seasons. It seems like only yesterday when he went off to college, and now he's done and will be going out into the world on his own. How exciting for him.
Abby: Mom and Dad are very proud of the five of us kids.
Sam: Do you think they know that we get on this computer and write this column every month? I mean, if they DID, they'd be REALLY proud.
Abby: Maybe we should send them an e-mail and include the URL for this web site, and then watch and see how they react when they get it. We could sign it "The Kids Who Still Live At Home." Do you think they'd know who it was?
Sam: Perhaps. They're fairly clever.
Abby: At times.
Sam: And after we do that, I think we should start writing that book we've been contemplating--the one on Why Humans Do The Things They Do.
Abby: Do you think we have enough research data to begin? We want to ensure that it's as professionally-written as possible.
Sam: Well, we've been watching everyone who lives here for as long as we've known them all. We've seen their friends and relatives come and go, come and go, and come and go, season after season. We've noted every pattern and nuance that anyone could observe. Scientists say that dogs spend a large part of their time--up to 60 or 70 percent--watching their humans.
Abby: Really? I didn't realize it was quite that much.
Sam: Oh, yes. It's quite a lot. Do you know WHY we watch them so much?
Abby: Of course, silly. We're waiting for treats!!
Sam: Good answer, Abby old girl. That's right. We're waiting for treats, or for them to drop bits of food on the floor. Or for them to look at us and say "Good Boy" or "Good Girl," and then pat us on the head, or take us outside. Or for a run, even.
Abby: Sam, I just LOVE those words! "Outside" and "Run" are my favorite words in the whole world, after "Treats," of course.
Sam: Yes, Ab, language is wonderful, isn't it? So much can be communicated in so many ways by using language.
Abby: Sam, do we really know why humans do the things they do? Can anyone ever truly know?
Sam: Of course not, Ab. Humans are enigmas. Puzzling paradoxes. But if we don't at least TRY, we'll never advance our understanding of this odd species. There is so much to learn, and so little time. Well, actually, we have lots of time.
Abby: Not exactly. Scientists also say that dogs sleep up to 16 hours per day, which means that we don't have that much time. We have to sleep, then we have to watch our humans. Then we have to be ready when they say the magic words "Outside" or "Run" or "Squirrel." That doesn't leave much time to write our book.
Sam: Yes, but a good book takes a lot of germination time. A dog who is contemplating writing a book must spend days, weeks, even months snoozing in the sun while his or her unconscious mind gradually frames up the structures of the book, the details of the book, and the meanings that must be conveyed.
Abby: You're right, Sam. It IS a lot of internal work. It takes a lot of snooze-time. Thank goodness we dogs like to snooze so much.
Sam: Indeed. It is one of God's great gifts to the world that He made dogs sleep so much, and by so doing, made us intuitively brilliant. I'm glad to be a dog, Abby.
Abby: As am I, Sammy. But you know, I'm getting sleepy. And the sun has just started to pop up high enough to be streaming onto the living room floor right on our favorite rug. I think it's time for some unconscious "book-writing" time.
Sam: Brilliant, Abby. You ARE quite
brilliant. I think I'll just curl up here next to you and...
April 1, 1999 In Which Sam And Abby Plan To Watch Dad And Mom On The Oprah Winfrey Show, And Talk About How Parents Keep Kids From Growing Up By Not Letting Them Struggle
Sam The Cockapoo: Abby! Who is Oprah Winfrey?
Abby The Labrador: She's one of the most influential people in show business. She's an African-American woman, talk-show host, author, and actor among other things. Why do you ask?
Sam: Because I thought I heard Mom and Dad talking about possibly going on her show to talk about their new book, The 7 Worst Things Parents Do.
Abby: They did? Sam, that would be a wonderful opportunity for them to get their message out. They've worked long and hard to get this message out around the country. Dad is especially careful to try to explain what they mean by these 7 things when he is working with local school teachers, because they have gotten so frustrated over the past decade as their efforts to teach are thwarted more and more by parents who want to protect their children from reality, or who aren't willing to step in and create family structure for their kids.
Sam: Tell me about it. I remember about 16 years ago, when David was 7 or so and was about to shift to the traveling team in ice hockey, and Mom and Dad went to him and gently but very firmly explained that the traveling team wasn't an option--that it would be too disruptive to his health and too much stress on the family. He was angry about that decision for several days.
Abby: And then he came out of it, took up tennis, and ended up being co-captain of the high school tennis team several years later. And the family got to have some time together as a result.
Sam: I was reading in their new book that there are parents nowadays who actually file lawsuits against their kids' teachers and schools because their kids are getting too much homework! Can you imagine that? Suing a school for teaching your child and expecting your child to become competent? It's amazing what has happened to American children.
Abby: It's sad what has happened. Which is why Dad and Mom wrote this book. Look, Sam, something has happened to America over the past 20 years. Dad thinks it's because of guilt and the high divorce rate, as well as all the abuse and neglect that has been uncovered. But whatever the cause, it seems as if a certain segment of the population, especially middle and upper-middle-class families, have decided that challenge, struggle, and competence are things they'd rather not see their children face or attain because it makes some parents uncomfortable to see their children work!
Sam: That's awful, Abby! If parents make life too easy for their kids, the kids become emotional cripples, and then when it's time for them to fly out of the nest out into the great big exciting world of their own adulthood...
Abby: They fall flat on their faces and limp back to the nest, where they stay...INDEFINITELY!!
Sam: Uh Oh!! That's not good, Abby. If we had Kristin, Rebecca, and David still living in THIS nest with us, it would be awfully crowded! (:-)
Abby: No kidding, Sammo! We'd all be tearing each other's fur...er...or hair out.
Sam: About 5 years ago, Dad and Mom were watching a news special about male children still in the nest. The statistic was something like 25-30% of all male children between 22 and 30 years of age still lived at home. They followed four families in that situation, and in each case, the son who still lived at home had a very good job! One was an attorney, one was a physical therapist, one was a dentist, and one did something else--I forget.
Abby: I remember that, Sammy!! It was frightening!
Sam: And oh, so sad. So-o-o-o-o sad. I'm no psychologist, but when the interviewer asked one of the mothers if she still did all of her son's laundry, made his bed, cooked his meals, and so forth, not only did I feel ill, but the mother looked pretty unhappy beneath her nervous smile. So-o-o-o-o-o-o sad.
Abby: I loved what the psychologist said when they showed him the clip of the one young man who said he couldn't pay his parents rent because if he did, he'd have to give up his private tennis lessons at the club!!!! The psychologist said, very emphatically, "Move out!! Get a second job!!!"
Sam: Oh, Abby. I hope that humans can find their way back to a better path. As much as this is a great country, it's times like these when I worry a little bit. Kids don't want to struggle. Parents sue everyone at the drop of a hat because they want to blame someone for the fact that one of life's greatest joys is the reward of struggling with something and eventually succeeding. And when they sue, they rob their children of the chance to become competent. Then they wonder why their very intelligent son or daughter is working at McDonald's for minimum wage after college.
Abby: Do you remember how we met, Sam?
Sam: Sure I do, Ab. I was with my herd of cockapoos, galloping through the Canadian wilderness, when I fell down a ravine and broke my leg. I told the herd to continue without me because I didn't want the rest of them to die of starvation. It was a tough decision on my part. And then you came along, on your way back to Labrador, found me, revived me, and carried me hundreds of miles to the nearest hospital. We have been the dearest of friends ever since, even after moving here to Minnesota.
Abby: Right. Now let me ask you this, Sam. Do you think that the challenges we've shared together over the years--including that very dramatic first one where you almost died, and where I wore the pads off of my paws as I carried you for miles and miles---do you think those challenges hurt us?
Sam: Hurt us? That's silly, Ab. That's SO silly. Hurt us? These challenges made us the wonderful canines we are today. And they gave us a love that's beyond measure. No, Abby, those challenges are what have given us the meaning and depth in our lives, and the depth of love that no one could ever imagine. I wouldn't trade it for anything.
Abby: Me neither, Sammo. Me neither.
Sam: I sure hope parents reconsider their positions on these issues, and that if they feel so guilt ridden or so powerless that they can't lead their children into adulthood, that they get some help. It's such a waste to see a grown man or woman who's still emotionally back in early childhood because someone kept robbing him or her of the chance to struggle and grow up.
Abby: Such a waste.
Sam: See you next month, everybody. The snow
is almost all gone here in the city that is just a few cities east of
Lake Wobegon.
February 1, 1998
Sam The Cockapoo: Ab, this has been one of the warmest winters we've had in all of recorded history, up here in typically-frozen Lake Wobegon.
Abby The Labrador: And we've had so little snow that I've thought now and then that it's been perpetual spring. Although we did have that one week which included a morning when we awoke to 22 degrees below zero, just to impress upon us that this is Minnesota.
Sam: Yes. But all-in-all, it's been wonderful. Weather-wise, 1998 has gotten off to a good start.
Abby: So Sam, tell me, what do you think about Iraq?
Sam: Iraq?! Uh...well...okay, Abby, I'll tell you. I don't think anyone should have chemical or biological weapons. I think the whole idea of them is sick. I think whoever plans to use stuff like that ought to be sent to their rooms without their treats until they figure out that it's a stupid thing to be fooling around with. That's what I think, Abby.
Abby: Good answer, Sam. So, what do you think about Bill Gates saying that he's going to match or even exceed Ted Turner's 1 billion dollar contribuion to the UN?
Sam: More power to him. But I also think he ought to play a little fairer in the "browser-business."
Abby: "Bowser-business?"
Sam: No, Ab--"browser business." You know, Netscape vs. Internet Explorer 4.0. That's how we surf the web when Mom and Dad are gone. Acquisitiveness can be a positive trait up to a point, but after that point, it smacks of avarice and greed. I mean, Ab, did you ever notice what you do when we both get our rawhide chewy-sticks?
Abby: Um...uh...um-m...
Sam: You look a tad sheepish. We get the sticks, run over to the big glass sliding doors facing south, lay in the warm, morning sunlight streaming onto the carpet, and begin to chew. Then, being a cockapoo who is always interested in what's going on elsewhere, and perhaps having a touch of Attention Deficit Disorder, I get distracted by something. I scamper away for a moment, leaving my rawhide stick on the carpet. When I return, you have it in your big mug, and you've reduced it to a tiny scrap. If Dad or Mom is around, he or she will command you to let go of it, which you do, and then I finish it off.
Abby: Uh...yes...that sounds about right.
Sam: I don't know which is worse--that, or when you simply devour your own rawhide stick in thirty seconds, and then stand over me, drooling, watching, and waiting patiently for me to get distracted, so you can go in for the kill! Sometimes you're really clever, and you simply lay down nonchalantly next to me, gazing down at the floor, or out the window, all the while watching that rawhide stick out of the corner of your eye. I mean, Abby, it's really obvious, if you haven't noticed.
Abby: It is?
Sam: Haven't you heard Mom and Dad chuckling? They say, "Oh, look at Abby. She's so sneaky. She's just waiting quietly for Sam to leave that stick, and then she'll discreetly swipe it up in her mouth and it'll be gone before Sam knows what hit him."
Abby: They do?
Sam: Duh, Abby. Don't play dumb with me.
Abby: Okay, okay, okay, Sammy. We're dogs, for goodness sakes! We're dogs!! We may be the most intelligent, literate, computer-savvy dogs west of San Francisco and east of Manhattan Island, but we're still dogs. We have instincts. We have fixed behavior patterns and drives. We're still dogs!! And besides, I weigh 60 pounds and you only weigh 20 pounds, so...
Sam: Give me a break!! That was a nice try, but I don't think it cuts it. I think we're getting down to the meat of the matter, though. I think it's a question of What is enough? Saddam Hussein has so many gigantic, opulent palaces that he couldn't possibly use them for any purpose other than absolute greed in a million years; and yet his people live in substandard conditions by and large. Bill Gates has, what, 40 billion dollars or more? So, one billion dollars is a pittance. After a certain point--after one has enough--the fairness of it all changes, in my opinion.
Abby: Are you equating Saddam Hussein with Bill Gates? I think that would be a gross mistake.
Sam: I agree. No, I'm not equating them. But I think there is a related issue in both cases.
Abby: And in your mind, this is related to my desire to grab up your chewy stick when you leave it on the floor?
Sam: Maybe.
Abby: But I am a dog, and so are you. We eat what's there when it's there because in the wild, if we don't, we won't survive.
Sam: I know, Abby. And I don't deny that you're right about that. I just think that there's a philosophical issue here that deserves further exploration. After all, wasn't it Freud who said that human beings are basically driven by animal instincts? And if so, what hope is there for mankind if humans don't keep trying to rise above those basic instincts when the chips are down.
Abby: When the rawhide chips are down on the carpet?
Sam: Good one, Abby. You do have a flair for puns.
Abby: Thank you, Sam. You are a gentleman and a scholar.
Sam: Thank you, Abby. And if I didn't love you so much, I'd never tell you that while it bothers me now and then that I leave my rawhide stick on the carpet and then you devour it before I have a chance to get back to it, it really doesn't ruin my day when that happens. Cockapoos are naturally, instinctually curious and busy creatures, and while you are busily chewing up my rawhide stick, I am fulfilling my need to know what's going on around the house and yard at all times. And of course, every once in awhile, when you aren't looking, Dad or Mom slips me a treat while you're finishing off my chewy stick. So in the end, I guess we both get enough.
Abby: Hm-m-m-m-m. They give you a treat? I'll have to be more vigilant. Maybe I can get both your chewy stick and another treat from them. Or, maybe I could be grateful for the nice life that we have, and that we do, indeed, have enough.
Sam: Yes, we do. And I am grateful for that, and for having you in my life.
Abby: Thanks, Sam. You're a prince.
Sam: And you're my girl, Ab. Let's go pester Mom incessantly until she gives us a rawhide chewy stick. You can sing The Whiny Labrador Song, and I'll get up on my hind legs and paw at her. That usually does the trick.
Abby: I like being a dog. Let's go for it, Sam!
Sam: Righto!
February 1, 2006 In Which Sam And Abby Repeat Their Column From February 1, 1999, on Personality Disorders And Personal Responsibility
Sam The Cockapoo: Abby! We've nearly made it through the very worst part of winter. And despite some nasty cold weather and a lot of snow so far this year, the past few days have been downright lovely.
Abby The Labrador: You can say that again. Saturday and Sunday were sunny and warm--between 35 and 40 degrees. If you look at the graph of daily highs and lows throughout the year, you'll see that during the last week of January and the first week of February, the highs often don't get above minus 5 degrees Fahrenheit, and the lows are often minus 20 degrees, or worse.
Sam: When it's that cold, I last about 60 seconds and you last about 120 seconds outside before our feet begin to freeze and we try to lift them off the ground one after the other. It isn't an easy thing to do, and it doesn't solve the problem.
Abby: Yes, and every once in awhile you go a little too far from the house when we go out to do our business, and then you get stranded out there with freezing feet, and Dad has to run over and rescue you.
Sam; Yes. Thank goodness he waits out there with us when it's that cold. Otherwise, I'd freeze to death. And as much as I hate to put on those boots and that coat when we go for our run with Dad, I think if I didn't, we'd wind up having to go back to the house before we got to the lake, only a block away.
Abby: You look very dapper with your coat and boots, Mr. Sam. Very dapper. It's nice to have such a handsome best friend.
Sam: Your kindness is humbling, Miss Abby. Thank you.
Abby: So, Sam, I'm bored. What shall we read?
Sam: We've already read the Minneapolis StarTribune from front to back. And we've gotten our political updates from CNN. I don't know. Whatever you want to read is fine with me.
Abby: Let's see...hmmmmmm...I'm rummaging around on the top of Mom's and Dad's desk here looking for something...aha! Here's something interesting. It looks like a paper they're writing. Here, Sam, will you read it to me? I love it when you read to me.
Sam: Oh, of course I'll read to you. Curl up on that foam doggie bed over there and I'll put on Dad's reading glasses and get started. Let's see. It's an awfully long paper they're writing. I think I'll just try to condense it for you if that's okay.
Abby: Why, certainly, Mr. Sam. I just love the sound of your voice, that's all.
Sam: Okay. Well, the paper is talking about personality disorders, which appear to be psychological disorders that go way back into childhood, and that are more or less enduring traits, unlike problems such as depression, which seem to have a more definable beginning and end, and are thus often more transitory in nature.
Abby: Personality disorders must be more a part of one's personality than, say, an anxiety disorder. I know that sounds redundant, Sam, but I think it makes sense to me.
Sam: Sure. We're talking about something that runs a little deeper, and that may be a little more resistant to change, because it's more part of one's core identity, or lack thereof.
Abby: Go on, Sam. You're doing a great job.
Sam: Well, then it goes on to talk about different kinds of personality disorders, like narcissistic personality disorder in which the person is hardly ever able to empathize with anyone else, is completely wrapped up in his own self, and often talks in vague and grandiose terms, like people who are constantly describing things as "fabulous." It's not that "fabulous" is a bad word to use. It's just that when you use it all the time, and with a dramatic, affected tone of voice, it comes across as superficial and hollow. In fact, "hollow" is a good word to describe someone who has this problem.
Abby: What other personality disorders do they write about?
Sam: Well, then there's borderline personality disorder, which describes a person who, like the narcissist above, has almost no inner self or core or identity, which means that he or she is literally like a ship adrift at sea without a rudder. People with this disorder are at the mercy of their own emotional whims, so that one minute they can seem perfectly reasonable and whole, and the next minute they can be in total chaos. As a result of this, they tend to idealize people and then soon afterwards, get disappointed by them because they turn out to be imperfect, and then they try to destroy that person for letting them down. A popular book written for the general public, for people who may be living with or working with someone who has this problem, is titled something like I Hate You, Don't Leave, which captures the deeply conflicted and contradictory emotions and behaviors associated with this disorder.
Abby: Wow, Sam! That sounds like a big problem to have!
Sam: It certainly can be. People with borderline personality disorder often spend much of their adult lives filing lawsuits, butting heads with their bosses and creating havoc with the personnel departments of their employers; and creating chaos for their friends and families. Paradoxically, they can also be very successful in their careers, and when they aren't stirring everything up and trying to destroy those around them, they can be quite wonderful.
Abby: It sounds like such a painful way to live.
Sam: Oh, indeed. It surely is. Of course, many people try to justify a person's behavior because of the developmental-family history of the person in question. In the case of narcissistic and borderline personality disorder, there is little question that the cause is abuse or neglect in childhood. But the fact that a person had a bad childhood--yes, even a tortured one--is not an excuse for one's inappropriate, damaging behavior. Having no empathy for anyone but oneself, or creating near-constant chaos for self and others, is not justified by one's mental health history. And the only way for people to overcome these painful conditions is to take responsibility for their actions.
Abby: Yes, Sam. I agree with you. It is most unfortunate that the humans in this country have strayed so far to the extreme of seeing everyone as a victim of something.
Sam: Yes. It is most unfortunate. We are, after all, responsible for our actions, no matter what.
Abby: What can someone with one of these personality disorders do?
Sam: Well, it says here that they need to establish a long term relationship with a therapist whom they can trust--a therapist with impeccable boundaries so that the client isn't able to manipulate him or her--and then to stick with that therapist through thick and thin. The real test comes, of course, after the client idealizes the therapist and then begins the inevitable process of demonizing him or her. This is a crucial time in the therapy, because a therapist who can't handle the client's anger, or a therapist who tends to baby his or her clients, will blow it. At the same time, many clients will leave therapy at this time, just when they're on the verge of a major breakthrough in working through their disappointment. Learning to deal with disappointment gracefully--and to even deepen as a result of it rather than destroying everything because of it, is a key here.
Abby: Is that why many lawsuits filed by this type of person are so sad?
Sam: Yes. Granted, there are some legitimate lawsuits filed in these situations, but there are many that actually turn out to set the client back months or even years by sabotaging this process of learning to deal with disappointment. After all, life never gives us everything we want. But if, as a result of being deeply hurt as a child, a person believes that life now owes him or her everything, then trying to get "restitution" from life when all that really happened was just a normal part of life's normal disappointments can cause the person to get even more entrenched in his or her symptoms than if he or she tried to get through it without expecting life to "even the score."
Abby: I get it. Disappointment is part of life. Learning to deal with disappointment gracefully is one of the hallmarks of healthy adulthood. People with certain personality disorders expect, as a result of deep wounds, that life will eventually give them everything they want, which is impossible, which sets the person up for more and more disappointment. What a trap, Sam!
Sam: Aye, that it 'tis, Miss Abby. That it 'tis. And with that, I am ending our most learned discussion so that we can catch the last of that late afternoon sun streaming through the windows of the kitchen. Shall we?
Abby: We shall. For soon it will be dark, and we will have to wait 24 hours for that late afternoon sun to return. But I don't mind. Things often come to us when we least expect them.
November
2, 2005 In Which Sam
& Abby Think About How God Must Be Either Amused Or Somewhat
Offended By "Creationism" (and then they add some information on the
ongoing Katrina Investigation)
Abby
the Labrador: Sam, did you see that cocker spaniel this morning
on Good Morning America? She looked like she might have been related to
the cocker spaniel part of you.
Sam the Cockapoo: No,
Abby, I missed that. What was the story about?
Abby: She was taken to
the pound by her owner, who could no longer care for her, and a
63-year-old man waited and waited until he could finally get her, and
then he got her from the pound and they started their new life together.
Sam: So, what happened?
Abby: The man was backing
out of his driveway the other day, and drove right off of the nearly
vertical embankment across the street, and he and his dog plunged
several hundred feet, the car landing upside down. After about an hour,
the cocker spaniel got free of the car, and the man, hanging upside
down inside the car, told her to go get help.
Sam: What did she do?
Abby: She raced up the
hill, across the road, down the street, and up to the neighbor's house,
where she barked and barked until someone came out, and then she whined
and begged until the woman followed her over to the cliff, where the
woman saw the car, and called the police. As they were retrieving her
human from way down below, she paced back and forth up on the road,
until he was safe!
Sam: (with a tear in his
eye) That's such a touching story. Sometimes life is just too marvelous
and mysterious to even begin to explain.
Abby: Yes. Well, it's
interesting you should say that. I was watching CNN the other night,
and it appears that close to half of all Americans now believe that all
of the living creatures on earth have existed in their present form,
since time began.
Sam: Wha...???
Abby: And Americans
wonder why so many high-tech jobs, and why so many smart, talented
scientists, are leaving the U.S. for other countries. Despite the
overwhelming evidence that the universe, and creation, is constantly
evolving, close to half of Americans are so frightened, and so poorly
educated, that they choose to believe a simplistic fairy tale instead
of the facts.
Sam: That's
so....so....I'm not sure if it's more sad than it is scary.
Abby: You and I believe
in God, right?
Sam: Right.
Abby: And we believe that
God created the universe, right?
Sam: Right.
Abby: Don't you suppose
that God is either wonderfully amused, or somewhat offended, by this
silly explanation of His incredible universe?
Sam: I should think so.
After all, if you were an omniscient being, and you created creatures
with a big enough brain to contemplate creation, wouldn't you rather
create a fantastic, mysterious, wondrous universe that has been
evolving for over 33 billion years, so that those beings you created,
with those big brains, would have something to be in awe and wonderment
about for thousands and thousands of years, rather than doing it all at
once, with a sweep of His hand, so that there is nothing more to think
about?
Abby: Of course.
Sam: I am thankful that
we live in a universe of wonder and mystery, and I pray that no matter
how hard we try, we never become arrogant and grandiose enough to think
that we know more than God does.
Abby: Amen, Sam. Happy
Thanksgiving.
************Below Is An
Update On The Katrina
Investigation***************************************************
WASHINGTON (CNN) -- A Louisiana congressman says e-mails written by the government's emergency response chief as Hurricane Katrina raged show a lack of concern for the unfolding tragedy and a failure in leadership.
Rep. Charlie Melancon, whose district south of New Orleans was devastated by the hurricane, posted a sampling of e-mails written by Federal Emergency Management chief Michael Brown on his Web site on Wednesday.
The Democratic lawmaker cited several e-mails that he said show Brown's failures. In one, as employees looked for direction and support on the ravaged Gulf Coast, Brown offered to "tweak" the federal response.
Two days after Katrina hit, Marty Bahamonde, one of the only FEMA employees in New Orleans, wrote to Brown that "the situation is past critical" and listed problems including many people near death and food and water running out at the Superdome.
Brown's entire response was: "Thanks for the update. Anything specific I need to do or tweak?" (Copies of e-mails posted by critic -- PDF)
On September 12 Brown resigned, 10 days after President Bush told him, "Brownie, you're doing a heck of a job."
Brown is still on the federal payroll at his $148,000 annual salary. Homeland Security Secretary Michael Chertoff, saying Brown's expertise was needed as he investigated what went wrong, agreed to a 30-day extension when Brown resigned. Chertoff renewed that extension in mid-October.
Brown took over FEMA in 2003 with little experience in emergency management. He joined the agency in 2001 as legal counsel to his college friend, then-FEMA director Joe Allbaugh, who was Bush's 2000 campaign manager. When Allbaugh left FEMA in 2003 Brown assumed the top job.
Before joining the Bush administration, Brown spent a decade as the stewards and judges commissioner of the International Arabian Horse Association.
The e-mails Melancon posted, a sampling of more than 1,000 provided to the House committee now assessing responses to Katrina by all levels of government, also show Brown making flippant remarks about his responsibilities.
"Can I quit now? Can I come home?" Brown wrote to Cindy Taylor, FEMA's deputy director of public affairs, the morning of the hurricane.
A few days later, Brown wrote to an acquaintance, "I'm trapped now, please rescue me."
"In the midst of the overwhelming damage caused by the hurricane and enormous problems faced by FEMA, Mr. Brown found time to exchange e-mails about superfluous topics," including "problems finding a dog-sitter," Melancon said.
Melancon said that on August 26, just days before Katrina made landfall, Brown e-mailed his press secretary, Sharon Worthy, about his attire, asking: "Tie or not for tonight? Button-down blue shirt?"
A few days later, Worthy advised Brown: "Please roll up the sleeves of your shirt, all shirts. Even the president rolled his sleeves to just below the elbow. In this [crisis] and on TV you just need to look more hard-working."
On August 29, the day of the storm, Brown exchanged e-mails about his attire with Taylor, Melancon said. She told him, "You look fabulous," and Brown replied, "I got it at Nordstroms. ... Are you proud of me?"
An hour later, Brown added: "If you'll look at my lovely FEMA attire, you'll really vomit. I am a fashion god," according to the congressman.
The e-mails came from Chertoff, who oversees FEMA, following a request by Melancon and Rep. Tom Davis, R-Virginia, chairman of a House committee appointed to investigate what went wrong during Katrina, Melancon said.
Brown resigned amid accusations that FEMA acted too slowly after Katrina hammered Louisiana and Mississippi, killing more than 1,200 people. He defended the government's response and blamed leaders in Louisiana for failing to act quickly as the hurricane approached.
He acknowledged he made some mistakes as FEMA's director, but he stressed that the agency "is not a first responder," insisting that role belonged to state and local officials.
Brown could not be reached for comment Wednesday night on the e-mails and Melancon's charges.
Although Chertoff has not turned over all the documents requested by the committee, Melancon charged that the material received so far contradicts testimony by Brown before the committee in which he described himself as an effective leader. (Melancon's analysis of e-mails -- PDF)
Melancon used an e-mail sent September 2, four days after the hurricane hit, to illustrate his point. On that day, Brown received a message with the subject "medical help." At the time, thousands of patients were being transported to the New Orleans airport, which had been converted to a makeshift hospital. Because of a lack of ventilators, medical personnel had to ventilate patients by hand for as long as 35 hours, according to Melancon.
The text of the e-mail reads: "Mike, Mickey and other medical equipment people have a 42-foot trailer full of beds, wheelchairs, oxygen concentrators, etc. They are wanting to take them where they can be used but need direction.
"Mickey specializes in ventilator patients so can be very helpful with acute care patients. If you could have someone contact him and let him know if he can be of service, he would appreciate it. Know you are busy but they really want to help."
Melancon said Brown didn't respond for four days, when he forwarded the original e-mail to FEMA Deputy Chief of Staff Brooks Altshuler and Deputy Director of Response Michael Lowder.
The text of Brown's e-mail to them read: "Can we use these people?"
Melancon also charged that few of the e-mails from Brown show him assigning specific tasks to employees or responding to pressing problems.
On September 1, FEMA officials exchanged e-mails reporting severe shortages of ice and water in Mississippi. They were to receive 60 trucks of ice and 26 trucks of water the next day, even though they needed 450 trucks of each.
Robert Fenton, a FEMA regional response official, predicted "serious riots" if insufficient supplies arrive.
Brown was forwarded the series of e-mails about the problem, but no response from him is shown in the e-mails provided to the committee, Melancon said.
Katrina came ashore along the Louisiana-Mississippi state line, after being downgraded from a Category 5 to a Category 4 storm. It flooded 80 percent of New Orleans. It was followed about a month later by Hurricane Rita, which caused more damage and flooding.
Melancon and several other Democrats from districts directly affected by Katrina were invited to participate as a ex-officio members of the Katrina investigative committee, though they have no formal role. House Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi refused to appoint any Democrats to the panel after GOP leaders rebuffed Democratic demands for an independent probe.
This is the second time a congressional committee had dealt with e-mails relating to FEMA's Katrina response. A complete transcript of Brown's e-mail traffic during the Katrina crisis has not been released by the Department of Homeland Security.
October
1, 2005 In Which Sam
& Abby Reproduce CBS News Anchor Bob Schieffer's Essay About
Hurricane Katrina From 9-4-2005.
Bob Schieffer's essay at the end of Face
The Nation, Sunday morning, 9-4-05...
SCHIEFFER: Finally, a personal thought.
We have come through what may have been one
of the worst weeks in America's history, a week in which government at
every level failed the
people it was created to serve. There is no purpose for government
except to improve the lives
of its citizens. Yet as scenes of horror that seemed to be coming from
some Third World
country flashed before us, official
Washington was like a dog watching television. It saw the
lights and images, but did not
seem to comprehend their meaning or see any link to reality.
As the floodwaters rose, local
officials in New Orleans ordered the city evacuated. They might
as well have told their citizens
to fly to the moon. How do you
evacuate when you don't have a
car?
No hint of intelligent design in any of this. This was just survival of
the richest.
By midweek a parade of Washington
officials rushed before the cameras to urge patience. What
good is
patience to a mother who can't find food and water for a dehydrated
child? Washington
was coming out of an August
vacation stupor and seemed unable to refocus on business or
even think straight. Why else
would Speaker of the House Dennis Hastert question aloud
whether New Orleans should even be
rebuilt? And when he was unable to get to Washington
in time to vote on emergency aid
funds, Hastert
had an excuse only Washington could
understand:
He had to attend a fund-raiser back home.
Since 9/11, Washington has spent
years and untold billions reorganizing the government to
deal with crises brought on by
possible terrorist attacks. If this is the result, we had better start
over.
For those who wish to make donations to the relief effort, you can call
the American Red Cross
at 1 (800) HELP NOW, which is 1 (800) 435-7669. CBS News will have
continuing coverage
of the aftermath of Hurricane Katrina.
And that's our broadcast. Thanks for watching FACE THE NATION.
"There are immediate needs in New Orleans
and the Gulf Coast, and the
first priority is meeting those. But after that, we need to
think about the American community, about the one America we think we
are, the one we talk about. We need people to feel more than sympathy
with the victims, we need them to feel empathy with our national
community that includes the poor. We have missed opportunities to make
certain that all Americans would be more than huddled masses. We have
been too slow to act in the face of the misery of our brothers and
sisters. This is an ugly and horrifying wake-up call to America. Let us
pray we answer this call." --Senator John Edwards

Screen shots of the "looting" photos on Yahoo News.
"Looting" or
"finding"?
Bloggers are
outraged over the different captions on photos of blacks and whites in
New Orleans.
September 1, 2005 In Which Sam
& Abby Offer Some Pithy Back-To-School Advice
To Parents of School-Aged Children. Their Column Was Written Before
Hurricane Katrina Hit The U.S., So They Also Ask That Everyone Help,
And Pray, As Much As Possible
Sam the Cockapoo: Well, old girl. Another school year for
the kids is upon us. The Minnesota State Fair started on August 25th,
teachers are getting ready for the first day of school, and the sun is
just a tad lower in the sky--just enough to give us that first little
ache that comes with the beginning of the end of another hot, glorious
summer.
Abby
the Labrador: Four or five leaves have turned. It's one of those
precise moments in time. Frozen. When the day is so intense and clear
that you don't know whether or not to cry. You know that something is
ending and that another is about to begin, and you aren't sure of the
outcome--the nastiest winter in history? Another terrorist attack? The
most spectacular Fall colors since 1925? Or, will it all just be
a dud? And then, for just a moment, you aren't even sure if the summer
that is about to end was everything it was cracked up to be.
Sam:
It amuses me that people in more "interesting" parts of the country
gaze at us knowingly, condescendingly, patronizingly, and shrug us off.
"Their television ads are about farmers' herbicide and fertilizer and
machinery, after all. How could they have any real meaning in their
lives? How could they really have a soul?"
Abby:
A soul. That's rich. As if being grounded and solid and connected to
one's family and one's history is passe. Some people forget that
Minnesota is, or was at one time, the home and/or birthplace of the
Guthrie Theater, the Children's Theater Company, Charles Lindbergh, F.
Scott Fitzgerald, Eugene McCarthy, Hubert Humphrey, water skiing, Cray
Supercomputers, HMOs (a dubious distinction), Prince, Robery Bly, and
Garrison Keillor and his Prairie Home Companion. Lake Wobegon.
Sam: Lake Wobegon. It's one thing to become famous because you were "discovered" by a vast Hollywood movie machine, and yet another to become a part of the national soul because you did what you do in life, day after day, week after week, regardless of what others think about you. To build something from the ground up--to do what God meant you to do in this life--to do it on faith and from your spirit, despite the small audiences and the absence of fame, and then